Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Anet A8 or Hictop Prusa i3 ATL II 3DP

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Anet A8 or Hictop Prusa i3 ATL II 3DP

    Hi,
    i am trying to decide between an Anet A8 and a Hictop Prusa i3 ATL 3DP and have some questions.

    The Hictop is an aluminium extruded frame and Auto levelling but I have seen a reviewing saying that the Hot End / Extruder is not good, Blocks.

    Is the Hot End the same part as the Extruder.

    Whats the frame like like on the Anet for rigidity?
    Whats the Hot End and Extruder like on the Anet.
    I have seen some upgrades on auto levelling for the Anet what would be a good sensor.
    What is a Bowden mod and should a printer have this upgrade.
    i have been told the support for the Anet would be much better than a Hictop.

    i am a complete nube.

    :-)



    #2
    Welcome! Replies inline

    Originally posted by JonnyAlpha
    Hi,
    i am trying to decide between an Anet A8 and a Hictop Prusa i3 ATL 3DP and have some questions.

    The Hictop is an aluminium extruded frame and Auto levelling but I have seen a reviewing saying that the Hot End / Extruder is not good, Blocks.

    Is the Hot End the same part as the Extruder.

    -yes

    Whats the frame like like on the Anet for rigidity?

    -It's not terrible and there's plenty of printable upgrades available online for frame stiffeners.

    Whats the Hot End and Extruder like on the Anet.

    -I haven't had issues yet.. Been printing with inland brand pla that likes it a little hotter than other pla--210c vs 190c

    I have seen some upgrades on auto levelling for the Anet what would be a good sensor.

    -that depends on if you upgrade to a glass bed or stay with aluminum--certain auto level devices won't work through glass. Honestly, though, I've had no real issue with manually leveling the bed

    What is a Bowden mod and should a printer have this upgrade.

    -Bowden is a system that remotely locates the feed motor for the filament and feeds it through a sleeve to the hot end. Think of a bicycle brake cable and that is basically what it is. The benefit is a lower mass on the x axis carriage and therefore less potential for shaking and over shooting.

    i have been told the support for the Anet would be much better than a Hictop.

    -can't comment on hictop support but there is tons of support for the A8

    i am a complete nube.

    :-)

    Comment


      #3
      Welcome!

      The hot end and the extruder are two separate things, its just in the case of a direct drive system like the a8 and hictop the extruder is mounted right above the hot end, unlike the bowden system.

      I don't have an A8 but aluminium extrusion is going to be more rigid than the plastic frame of the a8, but as W0J0 said above there are many mods to improve the stiffness, as well as many other mods to improve print quality and performance. The best thing about the A8 is so many people have bought one and are continuing to improve upon it.

      I can't comment on the hot ends I haven't used either printer, it'll be a clone of some sort, maybe an e3d hot end. But if its really giving you problems it can be changed relatively cheaply.
      I personally have never used an auto level system, with a decent understanding of how the printer works you can get a good level manually, but its something that can always be added later.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by W0J0 View Post
        Welcome! Replies inline


        Thanks for the replies - very helpful - still not 100% sure which one to get :-) I do intend to build a hypercube so maybe I'll get the Anet (for the support) as the Ali Frame is not an issue.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by MikeyBoxP View Post
          Welcome!

          The hot end and the extruder are two separate things, its just in the case of a direct drive system like the a8 and hictop the extruder is mounted right above the hot end, unlike the bowden system.

          I don't have an A8 but aluminium extrusion is going to be more rigid than the plastic frame of the a8, but as W0J0 said above there are many mods to improve the stiffness, as well as many other mods to improve print quality and performance. The best thing about the A8 is so many people have bought one and are continuing to improve upon it.

          I can't comment on the hot ends I haven't used either printer, it'll be a clone of some sort, maybe an e3d hot end. But if its really giving you problems it can be changed relatively cheaply.
          I personally have never used an auto level system, with a decent understanding of how the printer works you can get a good level manually, but its something that can always be added later.
          As above many thanks for the wise words - can't wait to get printing eventually :-)

          Comment


            #6
            Now also looking at the A6. Seems that the A6 is the A8's bigger brother and the frame and axis design is better?

            Comment


              #7
              Well I did it, I have just ordered an A8 from Gearbest Black Friday Flash Sale £106 absolute bargain. Now to look for some PLA and other bits ready for when it arrives. Also need to start looking at the ‘must have’ upgrades such as the MOSFET.

              Comment


                #8
                good luck! i've heard good things about the a8, it will need some upgrades but you should get decent enough prints to get you started.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Anet A8 Auto levelling Reprap i3 3D Printer Kit comes with a large 2004 LCD display, high-precision nozzle, super durable motors, high import lead rods and large-sized aluminium printing platform. Therefore, this exceptional 3D printing kit suits to deliver high precision 3D printed works.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by MikeyBoxP View Post
                    good luck! i've heard good things about the a8, it will need some upgrades but you should get decent enough prints to get you started.
                    Thanks - I found loads of info on upgrades, first of are fan ducts, Mosfet, frame supports and belt tensioner.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      I've actually been lucky enough to snap up an aluminium extrusion hictop i3 for under £150 I've heard theres a couple of issues that I may run into but I'm excited to get building/modding!

                      Comment

                      Register or Login

                      Collapse
                      Working...
                      X